Alternative to Medicare for All

The recent political upheaval has created an environment where the country can finally achieve some kind of healthcare reform. The country has been waiting for this moment well before President Obama ran for the White House in 2008. That was 18 years ago. Yes it has actually been 18 years. What kind of reform and how successful that reform will come down to negotiations between the Democrats and the healthcare industry as the Republicans will likely be content to sit on the sidelines for years to come.

Some candidates ran on a platform that would give all Americans access to Medicare, dubbed “Medicare for All.” Troy Jackson defeated Susan Collins in Maine, Abdul El-Sayed trounced his Republican opponent with the potential legislation as part of his core values, Juliana Stratton, Angie Nixon and Peggy Flanagan all embraced the program as well.

While this is a fantastic campaign slogan, there would be some drawbacks and unintended consequences to enacting quickly crafted legislation. First and foremost, the legislation will likely never see the light of day. The healthcare industry’s political machine is most likely already churning, reaching out to Democrats and letting them know that capping healthcare spending could also cap hiring as well as research and development in the industry. This could curb the female-dominated industry and come back to haunt the Democrats in the next presidential campaign as hiring would slow and wages would begin to drop.

Think this isn’t true? Just look at California’s Proposition 40, otherwise known as the billionaire tax that was on the ballot in 2026. Not only did they not pass Proposition 40, but the state ended up passing Proposition 42 which prohibits the state from imposing new taxes on personal property. So essentially the state not only didn’t strike against billionaires, California did the exact opposite. All the wasted energy, money, and time just to protect the public from bad legislation. Let’s not waste the same time and money with healthcare.

But we cannot just accept the healthcare we have now. As a society we have to make improvements and have to continue to try and make healthcare more affordable. President Obama’s signature healthcare initiative, the Affordable Care Act (ACA), allowed people with pre-existing conditions to get healthcare coverage, expanded Medicaid, created a marketplace where individuals could buy healthcare, kept adult children on their parents’ healthcare plans, prohibited lifetime dollar limits and even gave people access to a doctor once a year. And this legislation was watered down from what the former president originally envisioned.

There is a reason why America is the world’s leader in the development of medicines and medical procedures. Death rates from cancer have been plummeting and recent drugs, including GLP-1s, have improved the lives of people all over the world and across all socioeconomic backgrounds. We can even get a full-body MRI for under $2,000 in the US if you pay privately. Capping prices on hospital treatments and healthcare access will likely curb research and development in the industry and slow innovation and growth in medical companies. While this seems callous to say out loud, it would be even more heartbreaking if humanity stops innovating after all the progress we have made in the last 50 years.

Putting those arguments aside, we are talking about a $5.28 TRILLION industry. Waking up one day and experimenting on such a large industry can have devastating results. This is especially true when the people crafting this legislation are unlikely to give up long-term gains in favor of short-term wins. History books are filled with repeated attempts of leaders making sweeping changes to complex industries they don’t understand or are too impatient to think things through.

A prime example would be China’s National Agricultural Development Program’s attempt to eliminate sparrows that were eating crops. They drove the birds to exhaustion and made every attempt to eliminate them in 1958. The next year, pests ate through tons of crops throughout China. 25 to 30 MILLION people died but the real numbers are likely far higher.

Taking sweeping action against such a large industry, without patience, on a carefully constructed industry by impulsive and unqualified congressional candidates will likely lead to catastrophic results. Leaders that take overarching brash action across entire specialized industries will likely exacerbate the problem of healthcare affordability. There are better ways to solve the problem but first we have to fully understand where the money is going before we can make improvements.

The Problem

Healthcare spending, both public and private, has grown out of control in this country and the government making slight changes may help make it affordable for more Americans without having to go through a European economic stagnation.

The US spends over $5 trillion on healthcare according to the National Health Expenditures report from CMS.gov. This equates to $15,474 per person and 18% of GDP. The spending can be broken down between government spending and private spending:

PayerAnnual spendingShare
Federal government$1.652 trillion31.3%
State & local governments$859 billion16.3%
Total government$2.512 trillion47.6%
Private businesses$967 billion18.3%
Households$1.459 trillion27.6%
Other private sources$341 billion6.5%
Total private$2.767 trillion52.4%

With this level of spending we could easily have enough money to create a public healthcare system that would not be unraveled by political bickering. If the nation would just elect a leader in the healthcare industry from each state we could form a coalition of people who would know what they are doing and would be able to guide the general public into a meaningful conversation about the healthcare industry.

If we want to break down federal spending by category we can look at the table below from CMS.

Program2024 spending
Medicare$1.118 trillion
Medicaid$931.7 billion
Veterans Affairs$117.6 billion
Department of Defense$50 billion
CHIP$31 billion

Medicare is entitlement spending and will not be touched by any Congress wanting to get reelected anytime soon. But what if we could provide better services for less money? If we spend over $1 trillion a year on medical spending for our seniors we can break down where that money is being spent and see if we can provide better services for more people.

The federal government spent $1.118 trillion in 2024 to cover 67.6 million people through four different parts of the program. Part A covers hospitalizations, hospice, and skilled nursing. Part B covers doctor visits, outpatient care, and medical equipment. Part C covers Medicare Advantage which is administered through private insurers. Finally, Part D covers prescription medications. This is too big to review in 1 article but there is certainly fat to cut from this budget and still retain the same services.

If we want to break down what money was actually spent on from federal, state and private spending, we can see the table below from CMS. This table shows where we can start to nibble around the edges of healthcare spending.

Spending categoryAnnual spending
Hospital care$1,634.7B
Physician & clinical services$1,109.7B
Prescription drugs$467.0B
Other health, residential & personal care$320.5B
Government administration$66.1B
Nonmedical insurance expenditures$306.0B
Nursing homes & continuing care facilities$219.9B
Dental services$189.2B
Other professional services$184.9B
Home healthcare$169.4B
Durable medical equipment$86.4B
Other nondurable medical products$128.7B
Government public health activities$157.6B
Noncommercial medical research$70.4B
Healthcare structures & equipment investment$168.2B
TOTAL$5,278.6B

With the government spending $2 trillion a year on Medicare and Medicaid, you would think we could easily provide healthcare to all of the United States. It takes $500 million to $1 billion to build a hospital based on comparative private hospitals that have been built in the United States. This depends on the location, i.e. San Francisco versus rural Alabama, and the number of beds in the hospital. We also have to take into account hospice and nursing homes as well as pharmaceutical drugs. And we wouldn’t just need hospitals, we could build urgent cares across the country in strip malls for under $2 million a pop.

If we did this we could use a hub and spoke design to cover the largest cities. In fact cities like Austin already spends over $200 million directly on healthcare. If the city took even 10% of this money and spent it on low cost urgent cares it could build 10 urgent care centers a year. It could then use these urgent cares to continue to provide disease prevention, immunizations, health programs for children and pregnant mothers, and other services.

The US spends nearly $500 billion on pharmaceutical drugs and that is unlikely to change as drug companies can hold patents for years to recoup the cost to research and develop those drugs. However, having a system to fill drugs with generic drugs vs brand-name drugs can probably bring that number down.

And that is just the largest big ticket items. If we reduce government administration, spending on durable medical equipment, government public health activities, etc. we could leverage synergy to provide more services to a larger group of people.

But the country is now impatient for the solution to our healthcare problem and will likely jump at anyone proposing something no matter how unproductive. Why not take time to eat around the costs of each one of these sections? Develop a pharmaceutical production industry in East Texas or northern Louisiana, automate new manufacturing for durable medical products or start small and start creating urgent cares.

The first step would be defining what each one of these sections does. Then identify how much it costs to build a hospital or urgent care, rather than just waking up one day and start screaming, “Medicare for All.” Maybe then we can start the long road to healthcare reform.

Posted on